Published on September 12, 2008 By Island Dog In Gaming

Spore is a game that has been hyped up for what seems like several years now.  However, with it’s release last week most of the press and fan coverage of the game has been limited to one thing……it’s DRM.  One of the top stories this week was an organized “protest” at Amazon.com where over 2000 reviews were placed giving Spore a 1-star rating because of it’s included DRM measures.  Forbes Magazine has an article about the piracy of Spore.

“EA had hoped to limit users to installing the game only three times through its use of digital rights management software, or DRM. But not only have those constraints failed, says Garland, they may have inadvertently spurred the pirates on.”

I have seen this over and over when it comes to PC games like this, and sometimes it seems the more restrictive the DRM is, the more the people they hope would be customers are just pirating the game. 

"PC games are massively pirated because you can pirate them," says Brad Wardell, chief executive of Plymouth, Mich.-based gaming company Stardock. Wardell argues that the driver for piracy is user-friendliness--not price. Instead of digital locks, Stardock requires users to use unique serial numbers which it monitors, in conjunction with IP addresses.

"Our focus is on getting people who would buy our software to buy it," Wardell says, rather than trying to strong-arm people unlikely to pay for the products into become paying customers.”

When I read this article the first thing that came to my mind was the “Gamers Bill of Rights” recently announced by Stardock.  This could possibly be a good time for others to take another serious look at it, and see how the success of games like Sins of a Solar Empire were achieved without the need for restrictive DRM measures.

Read the full article at Forbes.com.


Comments (Page 1)
2 Pages1 2 
on Sep 13, 2008

EA are too silly to pay attention. 

on Sep 13, 2008

"The tighter you squeeze, the more slips through your fingers."

It's pretty sad, really; they just don't seem to understand that they're shooting themselves in the foot here. Lots of people who would normally buy it want nothing to do with the insane DRM, and either don't buy it or even pirate it instead. It's literally having the opposite effect that DRM systems are intended to have.

on Sep 13, 2008

When Microsoft came out with the Windows Genuine advantage program, people were very very pissed off because of it.  It means that it punish people who actually owns a legit copy of windows.  Because if you get updates, you need to go online and get verified whether your copy is legit or not.

Now with the problem of piracy, the SD's impulse model is very similar to Genuine Advantage program.  It is in many ways, the best non intrusive DRM ever around in the sense it does not mess with your system.

I think EA is the equivalent of Microsoft in the PC game industry.  Or they think they are, hence, no one can boss them around and even more so, pirate their games.  Soo they feel that they have to tow the line and tell the whole world, you can't mess with us by pirating our games, otherwise no the entire game industry will go down the drain. Hence people who pirates the game will be made an examples of by having draconian measures in an attempt to curtail it. 

on Sep 13, 2008

The end result is in a year or so , Blizzard/Activision will be the new #1.

 

 

on Sep 13, 2008

Ea is not an equivelent to Microsoft.

Microsoft does NOT limit you to installing only 3 times, just on 1 pc.  If you call them up years later to reinstall Xp they'll do it.

EA =ENRON.

on Sep 13, 2008

EA's Rail Simulator works the same for its add-ons that have been released.  Only three installs before you have to buy them again.

on Sep 13, 2008

"The tighter you squeeze, the more slips through your fingers."

So true. Especially with DRM. All I'm seeing is more legit users frustrated, while the real pirates simply share a cracked version online. It's just not working, and is in fact quite counterproductive.

on Sep 13, 2008

Please not here  I cant read anyting on the spore UK fourm without seeing something to do with DRM or how EA (half the people have it in their sig) somehow sucks. but at least you can descuse it here without people comeout with complet rubbish like "EA should have said it might not work on laptops" when it says so on the dam box that it might not work or "the DRM is causeing this random crash in the game" I am on the verge of ingoreing and classing them as people who want to just complain for no reason and not that they actually belive what they say.

 

TheDarkKnight2008
Ea is not an equivelent to Microsoft.

Microsoft does NOT limit you to installing only 3 times, just on 1 pc.  If you call them up years later to reinstall Xp they'll do it.

*checks to make sure the black hole thing has not gone wrong*

must be a joke the worlds not ending and someone is saying Microsoft is not the most evil out there. But you can in theroy call up EA in years time and get spore working

 

PS the stardock bill of rights was posted on the UK spore fourm before spores release and I posted a link to that priacy & gaming thing yesderday (my time)

on Sep 13, 2008

since i cant get edit to work. i did have a DRM problam when i got the game it would not regester but i could still play it off line with anything i manually downloaded.

on Sep 13, 2008

Fifty cents that by now, Spore has been cracked, making its DRM not only unpopular, but worthless. Stick away from EA. They can't do anything right.

on Sep 13, 2008

From what i have heared it was cracked before release day.

on Sep 13, 2008

erathoniel
Fifty cents that by now, Spore has been cracked, making its DRM not only unpopular, but worthless. Stick away from EA. They can't do anything right.

 

What do you mean" by now?" Spore's DRM was cracked before the game was even released in the U.S. That's the most riotously comical thing about all of this, really. They pissed off (and pissed on) their customers and got nothing out of their efforts.

on Sep 14, 2008

Vinraith


What do you mean" by now?" Spore's DRM was cracked before the game was even released in the U.S..

Well it was released in Europe before the US so there is no  eason why the US release date should be the expected crack date.

on Sep 14, 2008

What do you mean" by now?" Spore's DRM was cracked before the game was even released in the U.S. That's the most riotously comical thing about all of this, really. They pissed off (and pissed on) their customers and got nothing out of their efforts.

Wrong, they got EXACTLY what they wanted, to destroy the resale market of their games. AND to force their most die hard fans to buy their game multiple times. (dammit, out of activations, i need to buy another copy...)

Ofcourse, I hope this is the end of EA, because EA is so evil, but I somehow don't think that is the case. The audacity of it all, is that they are playing it as if they are the victems trying to protect themselves from piracy (which has nothing to do with activation limits)

on Sep 14, 2008

But you were right on the money that piracy was unaffected in the least considering a cracked version was available BEFORE it was for sale in stores.

2 Pages1 2