Published on September 21, 2008 By Island Dog In Personal Computing

I was considering building a machine to use as a Windows Home Server.  I can build a new box, or even upgrade my current PC and build it with salvage parts for a relatively low price.  I have read all the reviews, but I was curious if any of our members have a WHS setup. 

I would definitely like to hear opinions about it. 

 


Comments
on Sep 22, 2008

I was part of the betas and loved it.

But . . I was running it on a VM and never got around to buildign out a new system.

on Sep 24, 2008

why in the world would you use a windows home server? it sucks.

I use an opensolaris server for its delicious ZFS. if it wasn't for ZFS I would be using a linux based one.

on Sep 25, 2008

taltamir
why in the world would you use a windows home server? it sucks.

I use an opensolaris server for its delicious ZFS. if it wasn't for ZFS I would be using a linux based one.

 

Have you actually used WHS?

on Sep 27, 2008

I have a copy of Windows Server... but bang for buck Ill just run linux-flavored servers...

on Sep 27, 2008

Is WHS something different from Win2k3 Server (or 2k, Nt4, etc.)?

I have a Win2k3, and a Netware 5.11 server (the latter one sits unused now - I have just been too lazy to copy the data off of it - a wopping 20gb of the stuff).

They are about as interesting as drying paint - unless you are studying for certs.

on Sep 27, 2008

For what it costs? I haven't had one myself. But, my ex roomate had one for a little while, an XP machine with simple file sharing would have served just as well.

I used linux for a bit but now use opensolaris b98. Shared as an SMB network via CIFS, and using secondcopy as a backup procedure.

The "it sucks" was actually not appropriate. I should have said "why pay for it for when you can get open source OS?" and since the server is just that, serving, and not browsing the internet. I have no need to worry about a virus cought on a windows machine spreading to the server via the network. (due to it being a different OS, not due to inherant MS weekness... although its nice that there are practically no viruses written for nix os, it is probably due to lack of marketshare) (not that it happens anyways, I run a tight ship, but for someone else it could be an issue)

on Sep 27, 2008

Is WHS something different from Win2k3 Server (or 2k, Nt4, etc.)?
Yes.  Introducing WHS